Mark, anytime you have a one sided scene with a well established model getting serviced by a brand new model we've never seen before (who doesn't even get naked), your members are going to go through the roof.
I don't care if it was Colin, who is universally loved by nearly all of us getting serviced: If you bring in a brand new
Broke Straight Boys model, I believe it's nearly unanimous that we don't want to see him sucking an established model's cock right away.
That completely ruins and detracts from the fantasy, and the overall premise of the site.
Any time you have a one sided scene with little to no reciprocation -- no matter who is in the scene -- people are generally not going to like it.
While some members do enjoy watching the pre-sex banter and interview type portion of the scenes,
Broke Straight Boys is not Larry King Live, Piers Morgan Tonight, nor The View. It's a porn site, and we joined to watch hot sex between two (or more) believably straight guys.
The current lifecycle of any one model's
Broke Straight Boys career goes something like this:
BACKGROUND
Broke Straight Boys provides three weekly updates, generally one update is a solo scene introducing a new model. The other two weekly updates, known as action scenes, feature sex between two or more models. Generally speaking, all models must reciprocate in some way otherwise the scene will be rated very poorly, and members will complain in the forum.
Model is introduced to us via a solo jackoff scene, and identifies his "straight credentials" in the interview portion. --> Model participates in his first scene with another, already established model, and gets a blow job at least, sometimes he will top his scene partner on his second scene. --> Model participates in full anal sex by his third scene, at least topping, but sometimes even bottoming as well. --> By his fourth scene, model is well established, and is pretty much expected to start bottoming, or at least actively participating in every other form of gay sex including kissing and/or cum eating (even
Jimmy Johnson has kissed in one scene, and he has sucked cock in one scene as well).
If model refuses to kiss and/or bottom by his fourth scene, he may be asked back for more scenes depending on his popularity. But with each recurring scene, regardless of his initial popularity, if model still does not kiss or bottom, members will begin complaining more and more with each recurring scene.
BOTTOM LINE: Unless a model is universally loved by everyone, if he doesn't somehow reinvent himself at some point, the members will get bored with him and will not want to see him much longer and will complain more and more about him as time goes on. His scene ratings will start declining, unless he has a really strong scene partner which will help boost the scene rating.
And never ever ever will the members be happy with a brand new model's first scene if it's one sided, the newbie does all the work, we never even get to see the brand new model naked, and the scene ends with the established model having to jack himself off in order to cum while the newbie remains clothed and doesn't even cum.
Again, this could have been a scene with Colin and the new guy and the members still would have hated it. Because as much as we love Colin, we would have expected him to do the sucking:
NOT THE NEW GUY WHO DIDN'T EVEN GET NAKED.
Mark, it's not rocket science buddy...I've suspected for some time now that Clay is totally, 100% straight but I'm now starting to wonder if you too are a straight man yourself and have no clue what gay porn viewers want to see?