You are correct Jon, that the majority of posters to the forum on that subject agree that the Josh & Shane video was a lot hotter than the sequel with the addition of MikeR. However based on the "ratings" voted on by the masses, including those who do not post, the first scene is currently at 4.5, while the threesome sequel is at 4.4, so there is not a great difference in the opinion of the "masses".
But obviously we all have our own individual taste in porn, so it has to be very difficult for management to produce scenes that will turn us all on. As Abraham Lincoln said:
"you can please some of the people some of the time, and some of the people all of the time, but you cannot please all of the people all of the time".
Yes Mike, we know that you would have loved the scene and told us how awesome it was even if MikeR was in it by himself, fully clothed throughout the entire scene, doing nothing physical except talking to the camera proclaiming how straight he is lol...because you like him.
Abe