Shane has a pornographic body in the best sense of the word and is conventionally handsome.
Logan comes a very very close second on those qualities but has the super-plus of an irresistible personality as well. Ricky has a lot of charm, and wasn't out of place with the bigger, blonder, buffer boys he shared the scene with, a great scene even if by the time the hotties ejaculated the contest premise had been forgotten.
I like the magic moment in a
Broke Straight Boys video when all the right elements of horniness, rapport, attraction, the lights, the action, the stardom--or maybe even just prostate stimulation--coincide, and the boy who's getting fucked gets turned on despite himself by what's going down. To see Ricky's willy not enjoying any of it took away some of the fun. But I bet Ricky is a great top.
On the other hand Shane and
Logan taking care of Preston would be tremendous.