I've had several very close male friends who were straight. I would even call some of my relationships with them "romantic friendships." Occasionally, they included sex. But this didn't change the fact that these guys' primary attraction was to women. I'm writing a novel right now, and one story is about two straight-identified men who fall in love with each other. I know some of you will say, "Um, that's the definition of gay." But I think sexuality is much much more complex than that. It's definitely not a standard recognizable coming out story. I guess one way of looking at it is this: When I've been in loving relationships with straight men and it turned sexual, sex for me was the expression of my love and desire, whereas sex for him was purely an expression of love. He had sex with me to show that love for me, but it was always clear that there wasn't an innate attraction to me. The best analogy for sex between two straight men I can think of came from a girlfriend I had in high school: "It was like chocolate chip cookies without the chocolate chips." It's a dessert, it's sweet, it's the same shape, and it will do in a pinch, and eventually you can think of it as a sugar cookie and maybe disregard the lack of chips. But you're always going to crave the chocolate chips.
One of the guys I loved repeatedly said to me, "Why couldn't you have been born a woman?!" I didn't take offense to this at all; in fact, in that moment I would have switched genders just to be with him. That's not a feeling I ever had at any other time in my life; it was specific to that relationship. So in my book I'm trying to imagine the difficulties and the rewards that two straight men would have in a relationship together. Rewards: they get to confirm their love for each other; they complement each other, and are there for the other. Difficulties: pressures from both straights and gays to get them to identify as "gay." (grey areas make people very nervous; it's one of humanity's most regrettable traits); having to decide to forgo acting on their major attractions; figuring out what to do with their feelings for women; feeling stifled in a closed relationship but feeling guilty in an open relationship.
On paper, it may look like two men could have a totally emotional relationship with one another and a totally sexual relationship with a women, but, like I said, sexuality's just not that simple, and neither are relationships; they kind of take on a character of their own. We're in a culture that insists on a strong overlap of sex and love, and even if you rebel against that notion, it's hard to discount it altogether. I'm not sure what the fate of this relationship in the book will be yet--(actually I think I do; I just don't want to think about that part yet.) It would be amazingly cool if I could find 2 straight guys who had fallen in love with each other, so I could ask them questions about the ins and outs of their situation, but I have a feeling those relationships are hard to find, even at a place like
Broke Straight Boys I'll probably just have to draw on what I know about my past "friends"' feelings about me, and then extrapolate to the other person's mirroring those feelings. Doing the relationship justice in all of its dimensions is going to be hard, but I look forward to the challenge.
So long story short, step it up dammit, Damien, and propose to that bitch Paul! Then I can pick both your brains. (just kidding: I know you guys aren't in that situation.)