It's nice to look at the whole package as you say, but I'm also turned on by a guys dick the most. I've met a guy to fellate him having only seen the picture of his D, and not caring what he looked like, or anything. He was in his 50s I think (said he was 30) - i still met him again afterwards.
Not that I've seen one that's not turned me on but some melt me.
I'm not really attracted to Casey's face, but his cock looks fantastic, I wish he was more current so the quality and quantity of his scenes were more. Calhoun I'm more attracted to, he's very sexy all round.
Srry I'm in heat tonight lol
Edit - no idea why this thread came up, anyway lol