• CLICK HERE To Join Broke Straight Boys & Instantly Get Full Access To Entire Site & 3 FREE bonus sites.

straight or amateur?

Smiley

Well-known Member
Joined
Dec 15, 2009
Posts
361
Reaction score
0
I was reading a miscellaneous blog this morning on Broke Straight Boys and the writer used the word "amateur" to describe the boys here. That stopped me. Well, yeah, they're amateurs* but that is just a part of them being straight. Plus there are plenty of other gay porn sites out there that feature supposed amateurs, including our own bonus site, Amateur Boys First Time, and I don't belong to those. I also know I have a straight boy hang up.

But the boys I've always appreciated, like Logan, Alden and Nu, have had a freshness to them that went beyond them being straight. You never quite knew what they were going to do. I think this is the reason so many of us like Mikey. He may be gay but he's spontaneous. He's still acts like being on the futon is a fun hobby rather than a job. They are all amateurs in spirit.

A few guys, Tyler and Diesal come to mind, were able to move from amateur to professional successfully. By the end of their times on the futon, they were pros. But one reason CJ was almost a drag by the end of his time here was that he didn't make this switch well. He looked bored. When will this scene be over? It became a job.

The more I considered this, the more I thought that I like these boys, straight or gay, because they are amateurs.

What do you think?


* And I don't mean amateur in the NCAA sense of the word, where if a college football player trades a jersey for a tattoo, he's a pro, as these guys are obviously getting paid for being here.
 
Well said Mr. Nine, and I agree with your point.

The only thing I would add is that you you think gays who are into straight dudes is a rarity, they aren't.

Let me put it this way: I rarely meet another gay who doesn't think of doing it with a straight dude. Maybe it's because we're surrounded by them, but it's true.

It doesn't mean that most gays attempt to actually pick hook up with heteros, but we sure are attracted to them. That is, if they are ones type.

That's why I say this straight boy attraction is NOT a fetish. And this attraction has been one of the keys to success to sites like this.
 
Well said Mr. Nine, and I agree with your point.

The only thing I would add is that you you think gays who are into straight dudes is a rarity, they aren't.

Let me put it this way: I rarely meet another gay who doesn't think of doing it with a straight dude. Maybe it's because we're surrounded by them, but it's true.

I agree with you. Personally, if I had the choice between getting dirty with a gay guy or a straight guy, I'd so choose the straight guy. I don't really know why, maybe it's something to do with "wishing what you can't have". I just find it hotter for some reasons than having sex with a gay dude. But again, you can be gay and tell me you're straight, that'll also work for me lol
 
Most of my gay friends have a relationship with a gay friend. Though I had sex with gay guys at first, it were the straight guys that I fancied. Feminine boys can be my friends but I really never fancied 'nelly' boys.

So I will never be happily married with a guy, because the straight guys I've loved are for the girls. Broke Straight Boys is a fetish site in my opinion because here two straight guys have gay sex, where they really would like to get paid for having sex with girls.

The favorite models here, have something more to offer than just sex, they have what I would call the X-factor. You can't learn it, can't buy it... have it or not.

PS: That's what makes you so hot too Smiley!
 
That's right, amateurs in spirit!

I was reading a miscellaneous blog this morning on Broke Straight Boys and the writer used the word "amateur" to describe the boys here. That stopped me. Well, yeah, they're amateurs* but that is just a part of them being straight. Plus there are plenty of other gay porn sites out there that feature supposed amateurs, including our own bonus site, Amateur Boys First Time, and I don't belong to those. I also know I have a straight boy hang up.

But the boys I've always appreciated, like Logan, Alden and Nu, have had a freshness to them that went beyond them being straight. You never quite knew what they were going to do. I think this is the reason so many of us like Mikey. He may be gay but he's spontaneous. He's still acts like being on the futon is a fun hobby rather than a job. They are all amateurs in spirit.

A few guys, Tyler and Diesal come to mind, were able to move from amateur to professional successfully. By the end of their times on the futon, they were pros. But one reason CJ was almost a drag by the end of his time here was that he didn't make this switch well. He looked bored. When will this scene be over? It became a job.

The more I considered this, the more I thought that I like these boys, straight or gay, because they are amateurs.

What do you think?


* And I don't mean amateur in the NCAA sense of the word, where if a college football player trades a jersey for a tattoo, he's a pro, as these guys are obviously getting paid for being here.

Dear Smiley,

I think you hit on precisely what old-time Broke Straight Boys fans loved about the site so. The models maybe were a bit curious, if straight, but they were adventurous at heart. If they were only for the "Sex" like Leon, then I say who can't relate to that also. What made the Pizza Boy trilogy or the hotel room with Leon and Scott so very hot and engaging was that you never knew what was coming, or cumming, next. Therefore, the spontaneity in the really classic Broke Straight Boys scenes was in full bloom.

Rather than being predictable, they kept you engaged and guessing with what is next, rather than dreading what is next. And even with the addition of "pros" to the futon, they had a certain self-assurance based on their prior experience to mentor or guide a curious newbie or near newbie into new heights of pleasure they had perhaps never dreamed of. Their professionalism that followed them, such as Jimmie or Porn Shane, meant they were knowledgeable and could radiate a sense of confidence a near newbie needs to be comfortable with to explore further, like in the scene with Shane and Josh. That was the magic, that along with finding boys that were open and willing to try new sexual experiences.

Regardless of the title of this site, I would think most of members would consider Josh from the very beginning as straight or no more than slightly curious, anyway. And, over time he was slowly won over at the very least to bi or somewhere approaching bi. Josh and Shane, when paired together, really won the hearts of the audience over thinking that there really was something going on with the two of them, something spontaneous, yet undeniable. I think most of us here want to see that in the future episodes, but at the current pace we may not have enough years left in our lifetime for this to evolve with most of the "Straight ONLY" Broke Straight Boys-2 models. Hence, no more magic.

I do not pretend to speak for all Broke Straight Boys members, but seeing what appears to be a romance here and there is "sweet" and "satisfying".:001_tt2: Therefore, Smiley, I have to agree with your comment stating:

"But the boys I've always appreciated, like Logan, Alden and Nu, have had a freshness to them that went beyond them being straight. You never quite knew what they were going to do. I think this is the reason so many of us like Mikey. He may be gay but he's spontaneous. He's still acts like being on the futon is a fun hobby rather than a job. They are all amateurs in spirit." :thumbup:

Terrific observation Smiley. This is the essence of what made Broke Straight Boys great!:blushing:


Sincerely,


Stimpy
 
Stimpy, I like your post a lot and agree with much of what you wrote. You make me want to re-watch all of Josh's videos, not just the one with Porn Shane, which I love.

That said, I never meant my post to be a dig at Mark's trying to make the site more straight. You are certainly welcome to take my observations to make that point but that was not mine.

I'd hope my observations are equally valid regarding both BSB1.0 and BSB2.0.
 
Twist and Shout!

Stimpy, I like your post a lot and agree with much of what you wrote. You make me want to re-watch all of Josh's videos, not just the one with Porn Shane, which I love.

That said, I never meant my post to be a dig at Mark's trying to make the site more straight. You are certainly welcome to take my observations to make that point but that was not mine.

I'd hope my observations are equally valid regarding both BSB1.0 and BSB2.0.

Dear Smiley,

I did not wish to dig at Mark either. Mark said he was working to fix problems and I trust he is. I just felt you captured a key ingredient that made Broke Straight Boys-1 so enjoyable, namely spontaneity in many of the scenes that later became "classics". I feel this factor to be constructive criticism in hopes of future changes. That is all I meant.


Sincerely misunderstood, but forgiven,


Stimpy
 
Hey Smiley,

Can I tell you something? It could come as a shock... so you better sit down!

Robert
 
I think the word is innocence. Whether it is a gay guy doing his first video, or a straight guy having his first mansex, it's fresh and exciting. Once a guy has been around the block, whether it is for his own pleasure or to make money, it loses that innocence. It's the same reason straight guys want to see a virgin.

Footnote, this makes porn exciting, but as for me, in real life I want a guy who's had some practice.
 
Smiley just lost his innocence

Dear Smiley,

You became a member of Broke Straight Boys in December 2009. On behalf of Mark and all members it’s my honour to inform you, that with your next post you will become a Senior Member of this forum.

Let me be the first to kiss the graduate…

Hurray, Hurray, Hurray!

PS: To every one who reads this, please PM Smiley with your best wishes… This young man is just to modest to admit he’d love it! Don’t buy any of his denials...
 

Attachments

  • senior2.jpg
    senior2.jpg
    12.5 KB · Views: 46
Last edited:
First off, no jokes about my "senior member". I turned 58 this week and old jokes are becoming all too real.

So these three guys are talking about getting old and the things they miss. The first old guy goes, "You know what I miss? It's taking a good pee every morning. When I was a kid, I'd piss like a race horse. Every morning, a solid stream of urine would fill the toilet bowl. Now every morning it's just a dribble, and that's because I've had to get up three times in the middle of the night to piss."

The second old guy says, "What I miss is taking a big dump first thing in the morning. There was nothing, but nothing, like a solid shit to start the day. I felt like I could take on anything that day. Now every morning it comes out in little pieces if it comes out at all."

The third old guy says, "I don't have your guys problems at all. Every morning, at 7 AM, I take a good pee. It's strong and wet and yellow and lasts for up to a minute. Then at 8 AM, I lay a log you'd guys would envy. My problem with getting old? I can't get out of bed until 9."

Thank you, thank you, Robert, for this special honor of becoming a senior member. It means so much to me, and I'll remember it for at least 10 minutes.

What did I have for breakfast?
 
Last edited:
So I will never be happily married with a guy, because the straight guys I've loved are for the girls. Broke Straight Boys is a fetish site in my opinion because here two straight guys have gay sex, where they really would like to get paid for having sex with girls.

The favorite models here, have something more to offer than just sex, they have what I would call the X-factor. You can't learn it, can't buy it... have it or not.
Robert, you and I both have that same dichotomy, in always having fallen in love with straight guys, while realizing that the straight guys will never fall in love with a man. And that is why I also agree with you that Broke Straight Boys is a fetish site. I would suppose that all members of Broke Straight Boys enjoy the fantasy of having sex with a straight guy, to some degree, but for the true devotees of straight guys, this site does indeed go towards fulfilling the fantasies of our fetish.

And that is why, when I saw the previews of Broke Straight Boys version 2, I sent you an email that it might be time for you to rejoin, as I knew that Mark's new product was right up your alley, as it is mine, and that many do exhibit that X-factor that you speak of.
 
And that is why, when I saw the previews of Broke Straight Boys version 2, I sent you an email that it might be time for you to rejoin, as I knew that Mark's new product was right up your alley, as it is mine, and that many do exhibit that X-factor that you speak of.

Hey Mike,
After your email and seeing Vinnie's picture, it took me just seconds to rejoin. :w00t:
You don't know what you've been missing until it arrives!
 
Top