Paris, the fact that you knew a bunch of straight boy next door types who remind you of Tyler is part of the attraction. He is that attractive, personable college kid living next door, or dating your sister, or working at the convenience store. I too have known guys like him, who I fantasized over during my more intimate, private moments.
And I too love the interaction between Dave and the boys. I think that he is perfect in that role. I have been a fan of this type of straight boy for pay videos since the early 70's when I found a bookstore in Greenwich Village that rented videos from some interesting studios. I became a huge fan of Old Reliable. The cameraman and interviewer was also named Dave, and he hired more "rough trade" type straight guys to be interviewed, strip naked, oil their bodies and jerk off. He sometimes had duos of straight guys naked sitting side by side and stroking, but usually no contact. He also had wrestling tapes where the guys usually were naked, and got into physical sweaty body to body wrestling. Cocks were usually rubbery covered in oil, but they often rubbed against the opponent during the matches. When the wrestling was over, the models often jerked off separately but on the same wrestling mat.
I also rented tapes from AMG or Athletic Muscle Guild. They were an older studio that originally had guys in posing straps showing bulges before nudity was allowed. They used to act out ridiculous scenes to get them out of their outfits to jockstraps or revealing underwear. The later AMG tapes had nudity and jerking off, but he still kept the hokey opening scenes to get the boys naked. I believe he had his boys in boxing scenes, but it may have been wrestling too. His name was Bob Mizer.
And finally I remember a lesser known studio, called Jaxon, where young smooth guys, often claiming to be straight, would be interviewed by a "Dave" type and strip and usually do a solo jack off. Occasionally there were duos or trios but I don't believe there was ever any touching, outside of incidental contact of touching legs or thighs while jacking side to side. The boys were twink like with pretty bodies and big cocks and creamy loads.
David and Mark have combined my favorite aspects of all these studios, that I enjoyed on video tape. I am not a big fan of " regular porn" in general, but
Broke Straight Boys is my kind of porn, and this is the only website that I pay for.
Mike