Scene Thread - Ethan Steel Fucks James Dawn

[BrokeStraightBoys]

Bob, SFPS01 explains why Ethan actually is more appropriate for this site than any other current models.

And when you talk about the history of this site, how can you forget Mike Robbins, Tank Shane, and of course Jimmy Johnson who all fit into the exact same mold as Ethan. And actually College Dudes is the sister site here for the gay guys, whereas Broke Straight Boys at least was the site for the broke straight boys! Ethan is exactly the prototype of what this site was based on, and I would hope that Mark or Sha could find more boys who fit into the Ethan mold, rather than the agency boys who go from site to site and have been fucked six ways from Sunday before ever setting foot on the set of Broke Straight Boys We desperately need more Ethan types here, in my humble opinion.

Well said and Jimmy said he would never ever bottom and ended up bottoming on another site. I think Ethan might do it at some point but these things take time.

 

[mikeyank]

As of this time, the scene has a 4.69 rating. The last scene to have a higher rating was Casey & Calhoun on April 3, with a current 4.75. I'm glad to see that over-all membership on the site enjoyed this pairing as much as I did.

 

[Dean B]

The scene is great - I loved everything about it and James and Ethan are perfect in every way!

They'll be in my dreams tonight!

 

[SGVBOB]

THEN, SFPS01, MAYBE Ethan should find ANOTHER site to CATER TO HIM, as the WHOLE PREMISE of this site/EVEN NAMESAKE, is STRAIGHT guys(Ethan), that will DO GAY THINGS, (in ADDITION TO sucking dick 2 minutes, and fucking a guy and kissing). THIS IS INCLUSIVE OF , BEING fucked, GETTING CUMMED ON, sucking dick for MORE THAN 2 minutes, as most other models have...or simply, reduce the FREQUENCY we have to see his redundant scenes. Is this any clearer?

Well SGVBOB maybe the reason he has done the least amount of gay things that any model who has been here so long is because he isnt gay and makes no bones about it. Last time I checked this site was Broke Straight Boys, not Broke Straight Boys Trying to be Gay. This incessant need to have every model who appears on this site bottom would indicate to me that there are probably other sites that would satisfy your's and a few others needs more fully. Not everyone joined this site to see all straight boys get fucked, and probably far from it. I certainly get no perverse pleasure from the prospect.

 

[SFPS01]

THEN, SFPS01, MAYBE Ethan should find ANOTHER site to CATER TO HIM, as the WHOLE PREMISE of this site/EVEN NAMESAKE, is STRAIGHT guys(Ethan), that will DO GAY THINGS, (in ADDITION TO sucking dick 2 minutes, and fucking a guy and kissing). THIS IS INCLUSIVE OF , BEING fucked, GETTING CUMMED ON, sucking dick for MORE THAN 2 minutes, as most other models have...or simply, reduce the FREQUENCY we have to see his redundant scenes. Is this any clearer?

I wasn't aware that you had made the determinations for this site of what the content and purpose and premise of Broke Straight Boys would and should be. I am glad that you have clarified for the entire membership, as well as the owners, exactly how and what Broke Straight Boys was meant to be, is, and will be!! I will close by saying it is very presumptive on your part to be the spokesperson for management and the membership. I am sure they will check with you before making any definitive plans for the future. The only thing that is "Clearer" is a great deal of arrogance. For the sake of civility, I will leave it at that. But please, for the sake of everyone else reading this, please save us your platitudes, everyone "clearly" understands where your coming from.

 

[mikeyank]

SFPS01, I would suggest you just let it go as I now do. Bob for whatever reason has a real distaste for Ethan. I've often tried to compare him to some of the straighter models in Broke Straight Boys history, who also never bottomed or did it only once because they were coerced to do so. The owner of the site Mark has commented several times how much he enjoys Ethan and that he is very much in the classic mold of a true Broke Straight Boys

You and I like Ethan, Mark likes Ethan and judging from the majority of the comments by our fellow forumites and the excellent rating that this scene has, most members like him as well. But it is impossible to get 100% of people to like anyone or anything. I suggest we not focus on the negativity that others may harp on, but rather to celebrate having had Ethan on our site and hope that he one day returns. I think he's adorable and he is one of my all time favorite Broke Straight Boys!!!!! Thank you Sha and Mark for bringing him here and thank you Ethan for all the entertainment you provided for me and others.

 

[SFPS01]

SFPS01, I would suggest you just let it go as I now do. Bob for whatever reason has a real distaste for Ethan. I've often tried to compare him to some of the straighter models in Broke Straight Boys history, who also never bottomed or did it only once because they were coerced to do so. The owner of the site Mark has commented several times how much he enjoys Ethan and that he is very much in the classic mold of a true Broke Straight Boys

You and I like Ethan, Mark likes Ethan and judging from the majority of the comments by our fellow forumites and the excellent rating that this scene has, most members like him as well. But it is impossible to get 100% of people to like anyone or anything. I suggest we not focus on the negativity that others may harp on, but rather to celebrate having had Ethan on our site and hope that he one day returns. I think he's adorable and he is one of my all time favorite Broke Straight Boys!!!!! Thank you Sha and Mark for bringing him here and thank you Ethan for all the entertainment you provided for me and others.

Your right of course Mikeyank.........I should have kept my mouth shut but I just had had enough of the "broken record" and constant harping about boys like Ethan and Jake. They are people, young men with their own minds, thoughts, feelings, needs and desires. Just because they are on a porn site doesn't mean they relinquish their rights to do what they are comfortable with and not do what they aren't. That is between management and the young men to decide....Thank you for your support.

 

[Repareur]

Your right of course Mikeyank.........I should have kept my mouth shut but I just had had enough of the "broken record" and constant harping about boys like Ethan and Jake. They are people, young men with their own minds, thoughts, feelings, needs and desires. Just because they are on a porn site doesn't mean they relinquish their rights to do what they are comfortable with and not do what they aren't. That is between management and the young men to decide....Thank you for your support.

I am one of the members who want to see him fucked but I still agree with you guys and I’m also tired of the broken record.

 

[mikeyank]

I am one of the members who want to see him fucked but I still agree with you guys and I’m also tired of the broken record.

Showing your age Rep. Chances are anyone under 30 has no idea what a “broken record” means. lol

 

[Repareur]

Showing your age Rep. Chances are anyone under 30 has no idea what a “broken record” means. lol

Find me more than 2 people on here under 30. Lol

 

[SFPS01]

Find me more than 2 people on here under 30. Lol

LOL Probably very true, unfortunately or not!

 

[tampa24]

I can confirm that both these guys currently have girlfriends. You guys wanted straight guys and here is two straight guys that put on an amazing show. Yes there is limitations which we try to push but this is Broke Straight Boys after all and that is what we try to provide to our members. I thought this scene was super hot and I really enjoyed it. Make sure you watch the before and after interview as well. I thought those were very interesting.....

WEll said Mark. WE wanted straight guys and we got straight guys. This is a really good scene. (As I hoped and expected it would be.) The conversation before and after also added a pleasant dimension to the context of the main event. I was especially intrigued like many of you that Ethan kind of admitted that he saw himself playing both sides of the street for a while, even as he saw himself comfortably settling down fully in the hetero life of wife (and kids?) eventually.

 

[Foxyman1961]

Ok it's a while since I commented on an Ethan Steel scene, and yes I know James was in it too but I did feel it was mainly Ethan's scene. Less than five minutes oral and the rest Ethan fucking James, sorry I got bored watching this. Very little variety, lots of moaning from James and Ethan talking rubbish, since when is James a Daddy? (mentioned at least three times). Not a great scene for me. I thought Ethan's skills were in improving, but this just seem to go backwards to his early scenes. James just stayed in one position throughout, I have seen James do some really great scenes with other models, this wasn't one of them for me. Disappointing I think is the word that sums this scene up for me.

 

[SGVBOB]

Easy Mike:

# of Paired scenes:
Mike Robbins=from 6/2009-3/2011 not even 2 years, 33, Tank Shane unsure because I never knew his nickname/name on here, vs 'Tank Shane'- but still pretty sure proportionally LESS THAN Ethan, and had done more.

Bob, SFPS01 explains why Ethan actually is more appropriate for this site than any other current models.

And when you talk about the history of this site, how can you forget Mike Robbins, Tank Shane, and of course Jimmy Johnson who all fit into the exact same mold as Ethan. And actually College Dudes is the sister site here for the gay guys, whereas Broke Straight Boys at least was the site for the broke straight boys! Ethan is exactly the prototype of what this site was based on, and I would hope that Mark or Sha could find more boys who fit into the Ethan mold, rather than the agency boys who go from site to site and have been fucked six ways from Sunday before ever setting foot on the set of Broke Straight Boys We desperately need more Ethan types here, in my humble opinion.

 

[SGVBOB]

ANY Ethan scene is an "Ethan scene". I feel sorry for the scene PARTNERS, as he/ETHAN makes the focus on HIMSELF

Ok it's a while since I commented on an Ethan Steel scene, and yes I know James was in it too but I did feel it was mainly Ethan's scene. Less than five minutes oral and the rest Ethan fucking James, sorry I got bored watching this. Very little variety, lots of moaning from James and Ethan talking rubbish, since when is James a Daddy? (mentioned at least three times). Not a great scene for me. I thought Ethan's skills were in improving, but this just seem to go backwards to his early scenes. James just stayed in one position throughout, I have seen James do some really great scenes with other models, this wasn't one of them for me. Disappointing I think is the word that sums this scene up for me.

 

[mikeyank]

Easy Mike:

# of Paired scenes:
Mike Robbins=from 6/2009-3/2011 not even 2 years, 33, Tank Shane unsure because I never knew his nickname/name on here, vs 'Tank Shane'- but still pretty sure proportionally LESS THAN Ethan, and had done more.

Mike Robbins - 33 scenes, one brief bottoming.

Tank Shane, simply listed as Shane on the boys page - 15 scenes, including one brief bottoming.

Ethan Steele - 16 scenes, no bottoming yet, but he said twice that if he returns he probably will bottom.

And Jimmy Johnson 26 scenes, Never bottomed here.

However the larger point is that I am not alone in enjoying a "straight" boy on this site who does not bottom. Porn is fantasy and my fantasy is I am watching a true straight boy fucking and getting sucked by a gay guy, (me in my fantasies). We all have our own fantasies, and Mike, Shane, Jimmy & Ethan fulfill mine and others who share my fantasy. It is okay to occasionally have that type of model here as well as the vast majority who do it all from the git-go. Why do people object to Mark and Sha and previous directors Clay & David satisfying all members of the audience on occasion? Why not let us all get our jollies, at least some of the time, as we are all paying members?

 

[tampa24]

Ok it's a while since I commented on an Ethan Steel scene, and yes I know James was in it too but I did feel it was mainly Ethan's scene. Less than five minutes oral and the rest Ethan fucking James, sorry I got bored watching this. Very little variety, lots of moaning from James and Ethan talking rubbish, since when is James a Daddy? (mentioned at least three times). Not a great scene for me. I thought Ethan's skills were in improving, but this just seem to go backwards to his early scenes. James just stayed in one position throughout, I have seen James do some really great scenes with other models, this wasn't one of them for me. Disappointing I think is the word that sums this scene up for me.

I won't leave you hanging there Foxyman. While I I think I said it was a "very good" scene, I also hesitated to go much farther than that. It was a successful scene in my opinion because it has two very handsome models who are very popular in their own rights. (And for good reason.) They deserve their popularity in my eyes. I also happen to see their straightness as a plus and a positive. Beyond that, I don't see this one going down as as an all-time great Broke Straight Boys scene.

For one thing I had hoped for much more kissing here along with some more passion (even if it's only acted out) because we have seen that in some of Ethan's previous work which was especially well received by fans. It's hard to say though whether the dearth of kissing here was a personal choice of James, Ethan or if simply it just wasn't included or prioritized in the pre-planned choreography of the scene. This was a little more cookie-cutter, paint by the numbers type Broke Straight Boys fare here. There were some mild erection issues that plagued the middle and latter parts. But we men are not machines and can't always keep a flagpole at full mast from beginning to end.

So yes. I still think it was a good scene because I like both models a lot. And I enjoy simply looking at both of them. Especially together! lol That having been said, I admit I've seen better work from both of them in previous scenes.

 

[mikeyank]

So yes. I still think it was a good scene because I like both models a lot. And I enjoy simply looking at both of them. Especially together! lol That having been said, I admit I've seen better work from both of them in previous scenes.

You bring up a point near and dear to me Tampa. I have long said that what makes for a good or even great porn scene for me is to watch one or more beautiful guys get naked and have sex. Porn is totally visceral to me. I’ve never personally got those who criticize lighting and sets or the qualities that one uses in critiquing an artistic film. To me porn is seeing hot naked guys getting excited and performing sexually and getting me excited watching them perform. That is what makes for a successful scene for me. For me, these are two hot guys who both got off to what they were doing, which got me off and so by my porn standards this was a top notch, excellent scene.

 

[Repareur]

You bring up a point near and dear to me Tampa. I have long said that what makes for a good or even great porn scene for me is to watch one or more beautiful guys get naked and have sex. Porn is totally visceral to me. I’ve never personally got those who criticize lighting and sets or the qualities that one uses in critiquing an artistic film. To me porn is seeing hot naked guys getting excited and performing sexually and getting me excited watching them perform. That is what makes for a successful scene for me. For me, these are two hot guys who both got off to what they were doing, which got me off and so by my porn standards this was a top notch, excellent scene.

Were is Old Fart when we need him to go on about the lighting? Lol. I’m with you porn is about the Peter meter everything else pails in comparison.

 

[mikeyank]

Were is Old Fart when we need him to go on about the lighting? Lol. I’m with you porn is about the Peter meter everything else pails in comparison.

Exactly Rep! Porn is so much easier to review than main stream media. If we get a Stiffy, the scene is good. If we blast A load it is Great. No nuances, lighting or cinematography involved. Lol