Broke Straight Boys is my #1 favorite paysite too.
My #2 favorite is jockphysical.com. Realistic medical physicals with hot amateur guys, very erotic, and lots of sexual content in each update. True jockphysical is rather amateurish, not shot in high def, the lighting is often times not the best, but it is so realistic and hot...plus the scenes seem so real and believable (unlike
College Boy Physicals lol). Probably because most of the models on there are truly amateur and have never been naked in front of a camera before.
What is so SMOKIN hot about JockPhysical is that a lot of the time these guys (who are usually straight) get completely erect as they're being examined by Dr. Mike. They always end the scene by providing a sperm sample, which of course involves them jacking off on the exam table. Sometimes Dr. Mike has to help them to its conclusion. But there have been a few scenes where Dr. Mike was giving a rectal exam, and the guys literally shot a load as he was probing their anus with his finger...without anyone or anything even touching their cock! In one case the guy was lying on his back with his legs up in the air, Dr. Mike had his gloved finger up his hole, and all of a sudden the patient unexpectedly shot his load!
Nothing against
College Boy Physicals, but the scenes on
College Boy Physicals are too fetishy and unrealistic (ie the metal probe being inserted into the patient's ass, those horrendous yellow plastic things that are stuck onto their nipples, those electrode things that are put on the guys' dicks sometimes, etc.). Most of the "physicals" on
College Boy Physicals are usually so way out there, to the point of being unbelievable. Although some of the older scenes were really hot though, especially with Dr. Rimmerman...who by the way was HILARIOUS!
College Boy Physicals would be hot if there was more sex, less out there and unbelievable medical quackery going on.
Some of the newer scenes on
College Boy Physicals have been getting MUCH hotter though. Several months ago, most of the scenes on
College Boy Physicals were getting so boring I wouldn't even bother to watch them! Just a glance at the photo sets showed they were completely boring...and it wasn't helped by the fact that some of my least favorite models on there would be in never-ending series that went on for what seemed like 3 months at a time. And when the site only updates once a week, one series featuring my least favorite model(s) drags on FOREVER. I wouldn't even put
College Boy Physicals in my top 10 or 20 list.
Incidentally, I have continued to be very disappointed with the
Broke Straight Boys sister site
College Dudes. While I love every scene that Danny is in (with the pierced lips and the long, shaved, curved up banana cock), because I find him to be THE hottest guy on the internet that I have ever seen in my entire life, a lot of the other models on there are shockingly unattractive. There's this guy named CJ on that site, who has to be one of the most unattractive guys I have ever seen, yet they keep putting him in scenes. I just think that the BCB site seems to be really slapped together and not too well thought out at all, almost as if they round up any guys they can find (no regard to if they are attractive or not), get them to have sex, and turn the camera on and then let them go at it with no attention paid to the lighting, camera work, editing, etc.
But, BCB is still a relatively new site, so hopefully things will begin improving there one of these days.
Never really been a fan of Sean Cody.com even though it's one of the oldest, and most popular sites out there.
Not a fan of another one of the oldest and most famous sites, Straight College Men.
Never been a fan of Amateur Straight Guys. Although it might get better now that Doug and Jay seem to have sold it, they're now gone and thankfully they will no longer be insisting on getting into the scenes and into the action all the time like they always did before.
Not a fan of
Bad Puppy, even though they give you access to a TON of bonus sites, most of those suck. They are rarely updated, few photo galleries accompany the movies, the movies themselves are usually low quality and almost always feature models we have all seen hundreds of times before, on hundreds of other sites out there (i.e.
Austin Grant, Steven Ponce, Tucker Forrest, Shane Frost, etc).
Not a fan of Corbin Fisher either, even though I'm currently a member. Too commercial and fake, and they over use some of the models. Plus it's very boring, cookie cutter scenes without ever adding anything new or exciting.
I would like hazehim.com, dickdorm.com, and outinpublic.com more if they offered downloadable videos, which they don't. Streaming only.
I periodically subscribe to teachtwink.com off and on, but that site is usually too twinky for me.
Defiantboys.com has the potential to be a hot site, but the movies are obviously ripped from their dvds, and are VERY low quality. Plus, there are FAR too many solo jack off scenes and not NEARLY enough action scenes. So I wouldn't even put that site in my top 20 favorites because of those two issues. Although a lot of the models are HOT, and definitely amateur...which elevates that site a ton. If they would just have more action scenes, and have higher quality movies, they would move to my top 10 favorite sites.
I will say, I sometimes like daddymugs.com sometimes, for odd reasons. To me there is sometimes something very erotic about a hairy, large, older man (Daddy Muggs) getting it on with a young, smooth, tan twink. Although I don't really like that site though because it's always the same thing: Daddy Muggs ALWAYS does the fucking, he NEVER gets fucked himself. And while he features scenes with water sports (where the model pees all over himself), it's never any kinkier than that. Yet he won't ever swallow any of the twinks' cum. Yet he makes them swallow his sometimes though. It would be hotter if he got fucked once in awhile, it would be hot to watch a twink turn the tables on him, and dominate HIS flabby white ass once in awhile lol! But I guess if you want to see that, you can always subscribe to jakecruise.com . But to be honest, I've grown bored with that site a long time ago. Although I will say, there is one RED hot scene on there where Jake slowly brought Ethan, a 23 year old straight guy with a HUGE cock, into the scenes starting with a solo jackoff scene, progressing to a massage scene (where Jake massages Ethan), graduating to a bareback fucking scene where Ethan takes the plunge, and fucks Jake bareback...and HARD. It was unforgettable, and so hot! Ethan being a straight guy is totally believable, because I had NEVER seen him before, and he was in several straight scenes with a hot girl on their sister sg4ge.com site, and his cock was so rock hard it looked like it was ready to launch when the girls pulls down his underwear and starts fucking him, stays hard as he's eating out her pussy without touching his cock, and of course all but erupts inside her as he fucks her without wearing a rubber. All this before the gay scenes with Jake start...but it was so erotic because it was so hot watching hot young Ethan get so turned on by making out with, getting sucked by, and eventually reciprocating with (overweight, bald, unattractive, much older) Jake...ultimately ending with Ethan pounding Jake so hard as he fucks him bareback, and he is literally glistening with sweat as he fucks him all the while making out with him periodically as they fuck. SO HOT!
But after awhile, jakecruise.com got boring and the same old stuff too. His cocksuremen.com is a complete bore in my opinion, especially since he often times uses the same old worn out boring repeat bad actors who have made the rounds of every other paysite out there.
Ok I see this is getting VERY long and drawn out so I will end by mentioning one more site that I used to dislike, but which seems to finally be evolving somewhat: baitbuddies.com . It kind of has the same premise as baitbus.com , but not quite as repetitive. At least Bait Buddies mixes things up somewhat once in awhile, and it's not ALWAYS the very annoying and queeny Steven Ponce being the gay bait guy every time like it is on baitbus. Plus, bait bus has started adding some kissing into the scenes now, where they never did in the older scenes so it's starting to improve in my opinion. However, they still need to QUIT using Steven Ponce, Tucker Forrest, and
Austin Grant all the time. Although fortunately we don't have to see Austin in the newer scenes now that he has thankfully retired from porn. (Nothing against
Austin Grant personally, I just go completely burned out on him being in 99% of the scenes on 99% of the paysites out there about a year ago, he just became EXTREMELY overexposed, extremely quickly is all).
I will end, by asking does anyone remember the old paysite dudedorm.com ? Whatever happened to that site? It was one of the first paysites I ever subscribed to, around 2000 or so. It was kind of lame, because all you could do was watch like 12 different cams at a time, and there was rarely anything sexual ever going on in any of the cams. But once in awhile if you happened to be watching at precisely the right moment, one of the guys who was sitting on cam chatting with the "chatters" as we were called, would flash his dick for a split second. I understand that after I got bored with the site and unsubscribed, they would start having more sex, but I never got around to checking out the site and resubscribing to it before it seemed to just disappear into cyberspace. It seems to be back online again, but I tried joining it and they don't seem to be taking any new memberships. I'm just curious what the story is with dudedorm, it seemed to be a big site at one time, and then just disappeared.
Abe
However, I enjoy "Bad Puppy" because it has so many bonus sites included and, when waiting for an update from Broke Straight Boys, BCB, and Boy Gusher(all Bluemedia sites), I often resort to the many sites included at Bad Puppy. 
and prurient interests.
On the Broke Straight Boys forum from time to time, there will be a recommendation coming from a member that is especially noteworthy as a bonus Broke Straight Boys site. For the most part, try to follow these recommendations if you don't want to miss out on something really good!
But seriously I thank Abe for his comprehensive overview of the various sites out there. I will check out previews of many of the one's listed, when I find time.
I saw it and thought of d 
