I was all over the place grading this scene and ended up at 3 - average in my grading system. A few comments:
1. Any scene with Johnny starts out with a point just because of his physical presence. He is still mighty fine!
2. Johnny is a suck and fuck performer. Clay should not try to get him to do those "cutesy" things like stripping. It is just not him and he can't do it well and I'm sure it is as painful for him to attempt as it is for viewers to watch.
Kaden Alexander, on the other hand, has that unbridled enthusiasm that allows him to do such things and have fun with it.
3. The orals were quite good by both guys.
Kaden Alexander is really progressing well for a relative newbie and Johnny finally is going down on the dick further than a quarter inch past the head - and that's progress for him. So at this point I'm at a 4.
4. Then the anal comes along and it is sad for this big, 'ole bottom for the second scene in a row to have to take a point away for the anal part of a scene. When Johnny stays that close to an ass when he is topping doggy, that means he's gotten his dick in, but it has gone semi-flaccid and he doesn't want to pull out too far and have it plop out and have to struggle to stuff it back in. Proof of that was when he pulled out when changing positions and his dick was hanging there semi-flaccid. In the missionary position, it is easier to stuff a semi in the asshole which is what he did. By the end, his dick was rigid again and he was stroking with long pulls.
Kaden Alexander must have watched too many of
Kodi's scenes. He not only over did it with all the moaning and groaning, but also with the pulling on the blankets and flailing of the arms.
Kaden Alexander, you can get the point across with out adopting the Chi Chi LaRue school of porn acting.
5. Thus, I end up with a 3. By far not the worse I've seen here, but also by far not the best either.