Actually Betu, I think that yours, Jon's and Beth's definitions of what and who is hot, are much more common than my narrow definition of what turns me on. When I first joined the site, "lo these many years ago", I innocently thought that everyone who joined was looking for the same as me, which was an incorrect assumption.
The very straight appearing and acting models such as MikeR, Jordan, Tank Shane,
Jimmy Johnson, Jamie (from early BSB2), and others are often criticized and disliked by many who want the models to "enjoy" gay sex, including passionate make out sessions and total acceptance of both topping and bottoming. But I am also confident that there are hard core fans like me, who want to see very "believably" straight guys who come to
Broke Straight Boys as nervous, and reluctant and hesitant to do "gay shit", but are on the set ostensibly only for the money. If not, then I don't think that Mark would have changed directors, as the BSB2 scenes under Clay, had become just formula, stereotypical gay porn with two guys kissing, undressing one another, more kissing and then sucking and fucking, with no hesitance or revealing what was going though their minds.
This is why I am in favor of keeping
College Dudes as a totally separate site, for models and fans of pretty guys making love, and leaving "
Broke Straight Boys" as exactly what the three words mean in their truest sense. To merge the two sites, would totally take all interest out of this site for me.