Factors influencing my grade:
1. Romeo is the "top" TOP on the site with a personna that exudes macho studliness. Thus, if he is to be topped at all (and I'd prefer not, but understand that bottomming supposedly commands the highest pay, I can appreciate why he does so from time to time) he should be topped only by someone who at least is close to or on the same level of macho studliness as he. Unfortunately, Tristan is not. Thus, this flip-flop for me was ill-conceived.
2. Tristan, the nervous newbie's dick was hard after the oral part of the scene. He should have topped first while his dick was still rigid. But after bottomming, his dick became semi-flaccid at best, and he had to force it into Romeo's ass and by the time he got to the last part, it was just limp. Bad directorial call. Also since this is a one camera shoot, when the model says he is cumming, then the cameraman should get closer, unless he is nailed to the floor or something. If cumshots are the big payoff for so many of the members, then it would be nice to see them.
3. I am and have always been a proponent of kissing if it is organic to the scene - if it flows from the interaction between the models. That was not the case here. It was like one, two three, four sucks, stop and kiss; one, two three, four sucks, stop and kiss. Same way in the fucking part: one, two three, four pumps and a kiss, etc. If anything to me the kissing here took away from the overall quality of the scene.
Having said all that, I gave this scene a 4, albeit a weak one - very good in my grading system. The orals were quite good for both guys and Romeo was tops in topping. Tristan's less than stellar topping performance was more a bad directorial choice for this nervous newbie than Tristan's.