The ratings for all scenes are available to all of us, as it appears on the scene page for all scenes. But as long as you ask, the highest since last July is Stirling & Darron from a few weeks ago at 4.43 compared to the Richie & Johnny scene at 4.07. Our current scene of Darron & Izzy is very highly rated right now at 4.74, but it was only released yesterday so it is way too early to see where it settles in.
In the all time ratings on BSB, currently Calhoun & James from January 2020 is the highest rated scene at 4.78. Conversely the lowest rated all time partnered scene is Lucas & “Reluctant” Mike from February 2013 at 1.86. In all fairness the Lucas/Mike pairing only lasted for sixteen minutes as after Lucas sucked Mike and it was Mike’s turn, he said he couldn’t do it and walked off set mid scene, never to return to BSB. I am in the minority and found that fascinating and one of my more memorable scenes as it was very real, and I like the reality of BSB when we truly see a truly straight identifying guy going against his grain. Sometimes as with straight guys like Johnny Forza and Adam Baer it turns out great, but sometimes as with Mike, it does not work out at all. But that is the reality of life.