Overall, I gave the scene a 3, and that's not because of the models, it was because of the way it was poorly lit, filmed and shitty still photo. For me, I'm glad the guys had fun, but it really didn't come across that way with the choppy editing and bad staging of the boys; most of the time, we couldn't see all four at once...and isn't that what an orgy should be?! Look back at the work Johnny did on the 1,000 scene; just sayin'.
As for the models...damn hot; all 5's for me! You guys are all just beautiful! Please more of these guys...in better scenes, better lighting and better still photos, please.
I have to agree with most (but not all) of your post Beth. The scene didn't really catch my interest until after Ian and Brody were all done interacting with each other. Then it picked up. I appreciate that they did something out of the usual locations. Because of the awkward camera angles and so-so lighting, I looked very hard to see Ronan Kennedy's cumshot. I assume he came (cummed) but I didn't get to see it happen. Some very good models, good ideas, etc. Only about a 3-4 for me though. Obviously from the ratings, the broader membership really enjoyed it. Ian and Ronan Kennedy did especially well here!