With two threads on the same scene, I always go with the one started first. (Of course that begs the question why another was started later than the initial one, but that is a topic for discussion at another time.)
As to Ashton, he says this is the first time fucking a guy. For much of the scene his fucking was so frenetic that I wondered had he fucked anyone before. And there was the problem of his rather severe case of JFSFDS (
Johnny Forza Semi-Flaccid Dick Syndrome). In fact it was so bad for the first two-thirds of the scene, that his dick seemed to spend as much time outside Tanner's ass as in it. As to his two cumshots, I think I barely saw a drop the second time (and that was using a magnifying glass), so I guess that counts, but hardly significant enough to make it sound as if it were a gusher. Despite these negative issues from my perspective, I still gave him the average grade, 3. I like his all-American persona an if he can get less frenetic in his fucking and fix the JFSFDS, I think he has the potential to be one of our top models.
Tanner was Tanner. That smile, good haircut, nicely toned body, and dick of death. All that together with the best personality of any model currently on site makes him a jewel on our site. I gave him a 4.
The scene, a 3.